Broadway’s “Breakfast at Tiffany’s”: Inside the 1966 Musical That Never Officially Opened

In 1966, the Majestic Theatre marquee promised a new Broadway musical adaptation of Truman Capote’s “Breakfast at Tiffany’s,” starring Mary Tyler Moore and Richard Chamberlain. Produced by David Merrick, one of Broadway’s most influential figures, this show seemed poised for success. Yet, despite its star power and a familiar source material, it never reached official opening night.

An Ambitious Adaptation

The creative team behind this production included composer Bob Merrill and director Joseph Anthony. They aimed to translate Capote’s stylish 1958 novella, and its popular 1961 film adaptation, into a full-scale stage musical. The task was daunting: Holly Golightly’s world of chic parties, complex characters, and subtle drama does not easily lend itself to typical show tunes and dance numbers.

Star Power and High Expectations

Mary Tyler Moore, already famous for “The Dick Van Dyke Show,” and Richard Chamberlain, known from “Dr. Kildare,” drew immediate attention to the project. Their casting implied that this would be a prestige production blending television stardom with Broadway’s seasoned tradition. Ticket-buyers were curious to see these beloved actors step into roles that had become cultural touchstones.

Troubled Previews and Cancellation

As previews began, it became clear that the show struggled to capture the novel’s nuanced tone. Critics attending those early performances found the musical lacking in both cohesion and charm. Concerned about the production’s trajectory, David Merrick made an unprecedented decision: he canceled the show before its official opening night, citing ongoing creative problems.

A Rare Broadway Failure

This “Breakfast at Tiffany’s” musical is notable for its abrupt cancellation. Unlike many Broadway shows that at least open and run briefly, this adaptation ended after just four preview performances. To this day, it remains a case study in how even proven material, a top-tier producer, and famous leads don’t guarantee a hit.

Did You Know?

• Despite the setback, both Mary Tyler Moore and Richard Chamberlain went on to have long, successful careers on stage and screen.

• David Merrick was known for his bold decisions, but canceling a high-profile show pre-opening was highly unusual, even by his standards.

• Scripts, recordings, and production details survive, providing theater historians insight into what went wrong.

Though this musical never fully saw the limelight, it remains an intriguing chapter in Broadway history, reminding us that not every adaptation can recreate the success of its source material.